...As Falana seeks electoral, judicial reforms, warns against questionable judgments; Ikoli decries growing courtroom victories
By SAM POPOOLA, Lagos
A retired Justice of the Court of Appeal, Justice Oludotun Adefope-Okojie, has urged Nigerian courts to adopt a more proactive approach to electoral disputes, particularly those arising from violations of political parties' constitutions, unlawful substitution of candidates and other forms of internal manipulation.
She argued that the judiciary must no longer hide behind the doctrine of non-interference in the internal affairs of political parties where there are clear violations of their constitutions, the Electoral Act and the Constitution.
Justice Adefope-Okojie on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, made the call while delivering the 2026 annual lecture organised by Gavel International in conjunction with the Ernest Sisei Ikoli Foundation at the Lagos Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Alausa, Ikeja, Lagos.
Speaking on the theme, 'Electoral Process in Nigeria: Managing the Boundaries of Judicial Intervention,' the retired appellate court judge expressed concern that Nigeria's electoral process had increasingly shifted from polling units to courtrooms, with judges frequently determining electoral winners instead of the electorate.
She maintained that the ideal electoral system was one in which votes cast by Nigerians at polling units determined the outcome of elections, rather than prolonged legal battles.
The retired judge blamed political parties for contributing significantly to the problem through their failure to comply with their constitutions in the selection of candidates.
She identified flawed party congresses, unlawful substitutions and the imposition of preferred candidates as major factors responsible for the increasing number of pre-election litigations.
Adefope-Okojie also listed ballot snatching, vote buying, electoral rigging, manipulation and falsification of results among the irregularities fuelling election petitions across the country.
She regretted that these practices had often resulted in the emergence of elected representatives who were not necessarily the choices of the electorate.
Describing the situation as an aberration, she expressed concern over the alarming volume of electoral litigation in Nigeria, citing the 1,209 petitions filed after the 2023 general elections in respect of 1,280 contested offices.
Comparing Nigeria's electoral litigation figures with those of other African countries, including Zambia, Malawi, Kenya and Ghana, she said Nigeria recorded approximately 94.5 petitions for every 100 contested seats.
In contrast, Kenya recorded about 20.6 petitions per 100 contested seats in 2017 and 6.5 in 2022, while Ghana recorded approximately 5.8 petitions per 100 contested parliamentary seats in 2020.
She further disclosed that only 103 of the 1,209 petitions filed after the 2023 general elections succeeded, arguing that the huge volume of litigation had not translated into a corresponding level of electoral justice.
According to her, the statistics reflected a serious deficit of public confidence in Nigeria's electoral process.
She observed that countries with credible electoral dispute-resolution mechanisms, empowered electoral commissions and stricter rules governing election litigation generally recorded fewer petitions.
To address the situation, Adefope-Okojie advocated effective mechanisms for resolving electoral grievances before they escalate into court cases, rather than allowing virtually every dispute to proceed directly to election petition tribunals.
She urged political parties to respect their constitutions and strictly adhere to established procedures for selecting candidates.
She also called on the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to discharge its responsibilities impartially and ensure that elections were conducted in accordance with the law.
However, she maintained that the judiciary must reconsider its traditional reluctance to interfere in the internal affairs of political parties, particularly where clear breaches of party constitutions and relevant electoral laws had occurred.
With Nigeria preparing for the 2027 general elections under the Electoral Act 2026, she stressed the need for a more credible electoral process and a judiciary committed to enforcing the law without undermining the democratic choices of the people.
In his intervention, a Lagos-based lawyer and Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), Femi Falana, called for comprehensive reforms of Nigeria's electoral and judicial systems, warning that the manipulation of election outcomes through court judgments posed a serious threat to democracy.
Falana urged the media, judiciary, political parties and civil society organisations to intensify efforts to combat electoral malpractice, political impunity and violence ahead of future elections.
The human rights lawyer insisted that Nigeria must stop sacrificing justice on the altar of technicalities, arguing that the country could no longer tolerate situations in which candidates who genuinely won elections were allegedly denied their mandates through questionable judicial decisions.
He said electoral disputes should be resolved in ways that strengthened public confidence in the judiciary rather than creating situations that ridiculed the nation's highest courts.
Falana expressed concern that controversial electoral judgments had exposed the judiciary, particularly the Supreme Court, to public ridicule and weakened confidence in the country's electoral process.
Describing election petitions as one of the major sources of embarrassment for the Nigerian judiciary, he urged legal practitioners and policymakers to address the underlying problems before the next electoral cycle.
The SAN also condemned the alleged use of public funds by state governments to erect expensive billboards promoting ruling political parties, while opposition parties struggled to secure visibility.
He questioned how the country could effectively combat impunity when public officials allegedly disregarded constitutional provisions governing the discharge of their responsibilities.
Falana called on lawyers, judges, INEC, political parties and Nigerians to work collectively towards ensuring that elections were conducted and adjudicated in accordance with the Constitution and relevant electoral laws.
Earlier, the Chairman of the occasion, Chief Anthony George-Ikoli (SAN), lamented that Nigerian elections were increasingly being decided in courtrooms rather than at polling units.
In his keynote address, the senior lawyer observed that the judiciary had moved from the periphery to the centre of Nigeria's electoral process since the beginning of the Fourth Republic in 1999.
According to him, candidates are now routinely nominated, disqualified, substituted or reinstated through court orders, while election results are frequently subjected to litigation before election petition tribunals and appellate courts.
He noted that the development had popularised the expression, 'victory in the courtroom,' reflecting the growing perception that winning an election at the polling unit was no longer sufficient to secure political office.
Earlier in his introductory remarks, the Publisher of Gavel International, Mustapha Ogunsakin, described the lecture's theme as particularly relevant, noting that it raised fundamental questions about protecting electoral integrity without undermining the constitutional responsibilities of other institutions or the sovereignty of the Nigerian people.



0 Comments